Pumpkin Butter from Scratch Recipe

I absolutely love this Pumpkin Butter from Scratch Recipe because it captures all the cozy flavors of fall in a creamy, luscious spread that feels homemade and special. When I first tried making pumpkin butter myself, I was amazed at how simple it was to get that deep, spiced sweetness without having to buy anything processed. You’ll find that this recipe goes beyond just being a condiment—it turns breakfast and snacks into moments of joy.

This recipe works wonderfully year-round, not just in autumn, because it’s so versatile. Whether you spread it on warm toast, swirl it into yogurt, or dollop it over oatmeal, pumpkin butter from scratch adds a richness and warmth that store-bought jars can’t match. Trust me, once you make it yourself, you’ll keep coming back to this Pumpkin Butter from Scratch Recipe again and again.

this …

Ingredients You’ll Need

The beauty of this Pumpkin Butter from Scratch Recipe is how these ingredients work together to create a rich, comforting spread without fuss. Picking good quality brown sugar and apple cider really elevates the flavor, so I recommend looking for pure, fresh juice or cider at the store or farmer’s market.

• Homemade pumpkin puree: I love using homemade puree for the freshest taste and control over texture, but canned pumpkin puree works great too—just skip anything labeled as pumpkin pie filling.
• Brown sugar: Using packed brown sugar adds a deep molasses sweetness that pairs beautifully with pumpkin’s earthiness.
• Apple cider or juice: Apple cider brings a lovely fruity brightness that balances the richness of the pumpkin and sugar.
• Vanilla extract: Just a splash enhances all the flavors and rounds out the sweetness.
• Cinnamon sticks: Infuse the butter slowly with warm spice without overpowering the natural pumpkin flavor.
• Pumpkin pie spice: This is your signature spice blend here, so adjust the amount to match your preference for warmth and spice.

Variations

I love experimenting with this Pumpkin Butter from Scratch Recipe, and you should feel free to customize it to your taste or dietary needs. Whether you want it spicier or a little less sweet, there’s a way to make it your own and still get that comforting pumpkin flavor.

• Add heat: For a little kick, I sometimes add a pinch of ground ginger or a dash of cayenne pepper—just enough to warm the palate without overwhelming the pumpkin’s sweetness.
• Adjust sweetness: If you’re watching sugar, try reducing the brown sugar and boosting the cinnamon and vanilla to keep it flavorful without being too sweet.
• Use maple syrup: Swapping half the sugar for maple syrup adds a rich, woodsy sweetness I adore during cooler months.
• Make it vegan: This recipe is naturally vegan, so you’re all set if that’s your preference!

How to Make Pumpkin Butter from Scratch Recipe

Step 1: Combine All Ingredients in a Large Saucepan

Start by placing your homemade pumpkin puree, brown sugar, apple cider (or juice), vanilla extract, cinnamon sticks, and pumpkin pie spice into a large saucepan. Give everything a good stir so the sugar starts to dissolve and the spices begin infusing evenly. This step is key for a smooth, well-balanced final product.

Step 2: Bring Mixture to a Boil, Then Simmer

Turn the heat to medium-high and bring the mixture to a gentle boil. Once boiling, reduce the heat to low and let it simmer. I usually set a timer for 30 to 40 minutes and stir frequently—this helps prevent burning on the bottom and encourages thickening. You’ll know it’s done when it coats the back of a spoon like a thick, silky jam.

Step 3: Adjust Spices and Cool

Once thickened, taste your pumpkin butter and add more pumpkin pie spice or cinnamon if you want a bolder flavor. Remove the cinnamon sticks before transferring the butter to a jar or airtight container to cool. It’s completely normal for it to thicken even more as it cools—this is where patience truly pays off!

How to Serve Pumpkin Butter from Scratch Recipe

Garnishes

I like to add a light sprinkle of extra cinnamon or nutmeg right on top of my pumpkin butter when serving—it adds a lovely aroma and makes it look super inviting. Sometimes, I’ll toss in a few toasted chopped pecans for crunch, which gives a nice contrast to the creamy texture.

Side Dishes

This pumpkin butter pairs beautifully with crusty artisan bread or soft dinner rolls. I also love spreading it on pancakes or waffles for a fall-inspired breakfast or serving alongside vanilla yogurt and granola for a simple, cozy snack.

Creative Ways to Present

For holiday gatherings, I’ve served this pumpkin butter in small mason jars tied with cinnamon sticks and twine as edible gifts. It’s also delicious layered in parfait glasses with whipped cream and spiced granola, making for an elegant yet approachable dessert.

Make Ahead and Storage

Storing Leftovers

After making this Pumpkin Butter from Scratch Recipe, I store it in clean, airtight glass jars in the fridge. It keeps beautifully for up to two weeks, and honestly, it tastes even better after a day or two because the spices have time to meld.

Freezing

If you want to stock up, pumpkin butter freezes well! I portion it into freezer-safe containers or bags, and it stays flavorful for several months. When you thaw it overnight in the fridge, it retains its creamy texture without separation.

Reheating

To reheat, I spoon out the desired amount into a small saucepan over low heat, stirring gently until warm. Avoid overheating, which can dry it out or cause the sugars to crystallize. Alternatively, a quick zap in the microwave for 20-30 seconds works in a pinch.

FAQs

Final Thoughts

Making this Pumpkin Butter from Scratch Recipe has become one of my favorite kitchen rituals—it’s simple, comforting, and fills the house with that welcoming fall aroma. I love sharing jars with friends and family, knowing each spoonful brings a little extra warmth to their day. Give this recipe a try and watch how quickly it becomes a staple you reach for again and again—it’s that kind of recipe worth going back to.

Print